Oh, I am all over this one, as I give this topic an inordinate amount of thought.
1) Bruce Springsteen
2) Bruce Willis*
3) George Stephanopolous
4) George Clooney
5) Pierce Brosnan
*The inclusion of my hair-challenged Republican dream date reminds me of that Sesame Street rhyme, "One of these things is not like the others, one of these things just doesn't belong ..."