THURSDAY THIRTEEN #49 -- Remembering the original songbird/trainwreck

THIRTEEN THINGS 

ABOUT JUDY GARLAND

Following the Britney Spears saga, I have had an overwhelming sense of deja sad because this reminds me so much of Judy Garland. Born Frances Gumm, Garland died at the tender age of 47 -- tiny and frail and looking 20 years older after decades of divorces, drinking, drugging, smoking and suicide attempts.

Like Britney, she was a child star. Like Britney, she was a tabloid target. Like Britney, she was such a powerful cash cow that no one was willing or able to tell her no as she self destructed.

But one thing Garland had that Britney doesn’t is authentic, overwhelming and ferocious talent. No less an expert on these things than Katharine Hepburn called Garland one of the most gifted indivdiuals she ever met. Judy was Dorothy and she took us “Over the Rainbow.” Kids not even born yet will journey to Oz with her. But there was much more to her career than that …

1. She was a major star in MGM’s Golden Era. She made more than 25 films for the studio in just 14 years. She was still in her 20s when they fired her after too many sick days, late days, days when she wouldn’t/couldn’t leave her dressing room at all. After all, it’s called show BUSINESS, and Garland no longer had a good ROI. This is where she was when she was Britney’s age. 

2. In her MGM heyday, she was awarded a special Oscar. Unlike Haley Joel Osment and Abigail Breslin, among others, child stars in those days simply weren’t nominated for “competitive” Academy Awards. Instead they were given mini Oscars. Garland received hers in 1940 for her “Mickey-Judy” musicals and for the immortal Wizard of Oz.

3. Those teen musicals are still fun to watch today. Directed by Busby Berkeley, the big production numbers are amazing. Garland is unfailingly sincere, even spouting ridiculous dialog like, “Hi! I’m Betsey Booth. I sing!”

4. She put her indelible mark on classic songs in those silly movies. I Cried for You, I’m Nobody’s Baby, How About You, and But Not for Me. Once Judy sang these songs in her strong yet tremulous voice, they should have just been retired.

5. Her version of You Made Me Love You was initially an MGM novelty song. In Broadway Melody of 1938, a teen Judy sings this to a photo of MGM’s greatest star as she pens him a fan letter. It begins, “Dear Mr. Gable, I am writing this to you …” She sings with such aching sincerity, it could have been me warbling to Bobby Sherman or David Cassidy.

6. She worked with Vincente Minnelli on Meet Me in St. Louis. Together they created famous musical numbers like The Trolley Song and Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas. They later married and yes, created Liza.

7. She helped launch Gene Kelley’s film career. He was a critically acclaimed Broadway performer, and Judy lobbied for him to be her costar love interest in his film debut: For Me and My Gal.

8. They also appeared together in my favorite Garland film, Summer Stock. It’s kinda dopey , actually. A Mickey-Judy/”Let’s do the show right here” musical with an adult cast. But it’s got Judy encouraging us with If You Feel Like Singing, Sing! and the unforgettable Get Happy! Love her in that fedora.

9. The backstory makes that number even more interesting. Throughout the movie, Judy is … well … fat. It works for the story because she’s cast as the diligent sister who works the family farm and supports the glamorous, frivolous sister with show biz aspirations. Suddenly, in the iconic Get Happy! number, she’s sleek and svelte. Then, for the remainder of the film, she’s heavy again. As the story goes, after the film was shot, Garland was hospitalized for a time (there were definitely pills, most certainly booze and perhaps a suicide attempt involved) and during her convalescence she lost a ton of weight. While she was trying to get well and clean, MGM was editing Summer Stock and decided it needed another big number. So when Judy left the hospital, she was summoned back to the set to shoot Get Happy! It was the last number she successfully completed at the old Dream Factory.

10. After she left MGM, she began performing on stage. She needed money. She had fame, but no job. Instead of doing plays, she developed a one-woman musical show. It’s still available today as a 2-CD set, “Judy at Carnegie Hall.” If you’re curious to hear what all the fuss is about, take a listen.

11. Then there’s A Star Is Born. She acts, really acts, in this one. “Hi, everybody. This is Mrs. Norman Maine.” Gulp. Oh yeah, she sings, too. Most notably Swanee and The Man that Got Away. She was nominated for an Oscar for this performance. Groucho Marx referred to her loss that year as “the greatest robbery since Brink’s.”

12. Judgment at Nuremberg. Another Oscar nomination for her heart-wrenching courtroom scene. (NO! There’s no singing! This is Judgment at Nuremberg, not Springtime for Hitler!)

13. Her variety show on CBS featured some amazing duets. It didn’t last very long because the network couldn’t sustain high production costs (due to their star’s late days, sick days, etc.) and middling ratings. But the series gave us Judy singing with Liza, Peggy Lee, Lena Horne and best of all, an unbelievably young Streisand. Their duet of Happy Days Are Here Again and Get Happy! still leaves me with goosebumps. Streisand, barely out of her teens and at the beginning of her career, looks stronger and more self possessed than Judy, who keeps touching Babs' arm as they sing. The veteran looks like she's getting support from the rookie. Watching this, you're not surprised that Streisand is the one who never went to rehab, or was multi-married, or went bankrupt. 

Ok, so I left out most of the really lurid stuff. If you want to read about the sex and the drugs, there are plenty of biographies out there. Some are harrowing, some are really juicy, and all are entertaining. Even when Garland was at her worst, she was imaginative , funny and rather brave, so her life has attracted successful biographers like Gerald Frank and Anne Edwards. But her chaotic and self-destructive personal life can’t overwhelm her sumptuous body of work.

Put your link in comments and I'll mention you here:

1) Pjazzypar takes us to Hitsville USA

2) Don't Make Me Get Out the Flying Monkeys serves up chicken dishes

3) Chelle Y gives us a tour of her desktop

4) Sandy Carlson teaches Origami 101

5) Ellen B. has a volcanic TT

6) Lori has a TT your kids don't want you to read!

7) Morgan confesses that her kids are spoiled

8) Nicholas takes us from the bookshelves to the movie theater

9) Malcolm quotes Laker-lovin' Jack Nicholson

10) Open Grove Claudia gives us 13 rules for living

11) Susan Helene Gottfried takes us to Yellowstone

12) SJ Reidhead entertains us with a historical, western TT

13) Lazy Daisy and I have the same favorite color

14) Candy has a feisty TT

15) Damozel has a pictorial TT. 

16) Journeywoman shares her joy in her faith

17) Nicole Austin has an insightful TT about men and love and we womenfolk

18) Zenmomma encourages us to reconnect with our communities

19) Gabriella takes us down memory lane

20) Deanna shares the contents of a literary treasure chest with us

21) Patti composed her TT around the letter B

22) Tickled Pink has a green TT

23) Natalie is in love … with her new car, and here's why

24) Harlekwin puts the adult world on notice

Get the Thursday Thirteen code here!


The purpose of the meme is to get to know everyone who participates a little bit better every Thursday. Visiting fellow Thirteeners is encouraged! If you participate, leave the link to your Thirteen in others' comments. It’s easy, and fun! Trackbacks, pings, comment links accepted!

View More Thursday Thirteen Participants

Keep it to yourself

"They all stink."

"It's like choosing between the lesser of two evils."

"They're all as honest as used car salesmen."

"What difference does it make anyway?"

"I'm too busy to pay attention."

I've heard all of the above from people aged 45+ regarding Presidential politics. I wonder if these cynical and lazy citizens feel at all responsible for the casualties in Iraq, waterboarding, Blackwater, the heartbreak and shame of Katrina, and the mess that became of the US Attorney General's office. For it's their laziness and cynicism that helped re-elect George W. Bush.

I'd like to think that this is the legacy of Richard Nixon. That the abuses of Watergate so scarred us that we don't have faith in the system anymore. But that's too easy. By the time you're 45 or older, you really have to take responsibility for your own actions and attitudes.

One of the most exciting things about this Presidential election -- on both the Republican and Democratic sides -- is how involved young people have become: Barack Obama is drawing rockstar crowds of people 30 and under; Ron Paul is raising amazing sums of money, courtesy of his merry band of young internet experts. Jon Stewart and Stephen Colbert enjoy a predominantly college-aged demographic. This new generation seems to get it in a way their parents don't.

If their parents' generation can't share their joy, enthusiasm, excitement and involvement, I hope they can at least shut up and not rain on their parade.

Of course, I'm the kind of corny patriot who gets choked up at the National Anthem before a baseball game. (Which is why the doping scandal upsets me, too, but I'm going to stop now …before my brain blows up.)

Behold the winner of the NH Primary

Everyone wrote her off. Everyone was wrong. In the words of my favorite author, William Goldman, "Nobody knows anything."

Since I am gloriously comfortable with all three of the top tier Democratic candidates, I am glad she did as well as she did so that the nominating process continues, and all three of their voices will be heard as Democrats decide which one best represents the party.